Master Teaching

a blog for teachers who follow the Master Teacher

Questioning for Reflection

A friend shared a challenge with me. Rather than jumping in with advice, as is my natural tendency, I attempted to ask questions to help her figure out the problem on her own. At the end of my series of queries, she said, “Those are really good questions. Questions are sometimes suggestions, aren’t they?”

When you think of how professional development occurs, one of the first ideas that may come to mind is receiving feedback. Many of the mentors I’ve worked with find this idea problematic, though, because it suggests one-way communication—advice from mentor to teacher—when they hope to engage their mentees in dialog. In fact, this is so important to them that a primary concern is asking good questions. But as my conversation above illustrates, doing so is really hard. Let’s answer some questions about questions and see how both asking and responding require some finesse.

Why are questions important when stepping toward professional development?

Questions encourage reflection and autonomous learning and lead toward the final destination—ownership of your professional development. Which are you more likely to take ownership of: advice given by your mentor or a problem you solve collaboratively as you answer her/his questions?

What types of questions work best?

What kinds of questions lead to reflection and ownership? It might help to think about their purpose, the answers they may elicit, and their potential effect on the listener. For example, do they lead you around to a “right” answer or to explore an issue collaboratively with your mentor?

The chart[1] linked here—Bloom’s Taxonomy for Professional Development—shows one practical way of thinking about types of questions. It’s based on the revised version of Bloom’s Taxonomy with a potential question for teachers at each of the six levels plus a seventh that allows for exploration of values benchmarks or needs. The questions/levels are listed from surface to deep. Which types/levels would help your growth as a teacher? Why?

What role does the questioner play?

Reflecting back on the opening conversation, I consciously attempted to listen well. At least I hope I didn’t interrupt too many times. Obviously, I tried to respond with questions rather than statements as I tried to encourage my friend to take ownership. Perhaps, though, I also needed to be open to different ideas. Could my wording, tone of voice, or facial expression have communicated an advice-giving intent rather than a willingness to learn and collaborate?

What else should the questioner do or not do?

What role does the teacher play?

Asking good questions is challenging. Answering them well can also be difficult. After reflecting on professional development interactions I’ve had (as a mentor or teacher), here are two things you could do to make your mentor’s job easier. What would you add?

  1. Respond reflectively. Some of the words that come to mind here include: consider, contemplate, ponder, elaborate, enlarge or expand on. If you’re a thinker (like I am), you may need to suggest a different mode of communication to your mentor. Email, for example, would give you time to consider and then respond reflectively.
  2. Answer with critical self-awareness. In other words, be open and honest, about weaknesses and strengths, with yourself first and then also your mentor.

As I’ve written this post and reflected on my questions and responses in professional development settings, I can’t help but contemplate other situations. How about you? In what relationships is the Master Teacher encouraging you to be a better questioner? In which ones do you need to respond reflectively and with critical self-awareness?

[1]   This chart is adapted from Melissa K. Smith and Marilyn Lewis, Supporting the Professional Development of English Language Teachers: Facilitative Mentoring, (New York: Routledge, forthcoming).

Further exploration

  • All of the posts in this professional development series draw from a forthcoming book:  Supporting the Professional Development of English Language Teachers: Facilitative Mentoring by Melissa K. Smith and Marilyn Lewis, (New York: Routledge). We’ll let you know here on Master Teaching when it’s available for purchase. (Both paper and e-versions will be published at the same time.
  • For more on ways of asking questions: “Toward Facilitative Mentoring and Catalytic Interventions,” by Melissa K. Smith and Marilyn Lewis, ELT Journal 69, no. 2 (2015).
  • Bloom’s Taxonomy for Professional Development.
  • For more on Bloom’s Taxonomy.

What’s your perspective?

Questions were listed throughout this post. Please feel free to respond to any of them—or any other idea in the post—in the comments section below.

Try it out

1. Working with your (peer) mentor, look at your essential questions/outcomes from two weeks ago and make a list of 8-10 questions you could explore together as you attempt to reach those goals. (Some of the questions may be related to last week’s contextual factors.) Then, analyze the questions:

2. Make some revision based on your analysis.

3. Let your mentor choose some of the questions to ask while you attempt to respond reflectively and with critical self-reflection.

Post Author

Melissa K. Smith

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on October 18, 2017 by in learning teaching, Melissa K. Smith, professional development, reflective teaching.



Photo Credit: Eric Fischer via Compfight cc
%d bloggers like this: